GOAT*
*except against NFC East in the Super Bowl
| Rank | Player | Team |
| 1 | Aaron Rodgers | GB |
| 2 | Tom Brady | NE |
| 3 | Drew Brees | NO |
| 4 | Russell Wilson | SEA |
| 5 | Mathew Stafford | DET |
| 6 | Deshaun Watson | HOU |
| 7 | Andrew Luck | IND |
| 8 | Matt Ryan | ATL |
| 9 | Phillip Rivers | LAC |
| 10 | Cam Newton | CAR |
| 11 | Kirk Cousins | MIN |
| 12 | Ben Roethlisberger | PIT |
| 13 | Carson Wentz | PHI |
| 14 | Jared Goff | LAR |
| 15 | Eli Manning | NYG |
| 16 | Jimmy Garropolo | SF |
| 17 | Marcus Mariota | TEN |
| 18 | Derek Carr | OAK |
| 19 | Dak Prescott | DAL |
| 20 | Patrick Mahomes | KC |
| 21 | Andy Dalton | CIN |
| 22 | Alex Smith | WAS |
| 23 | Case Keenum | DEN |
| 24 | Ryan Tannehill | MIA |
| 25 | Blake Bortles | JAC |
| 26 | Sam Darnold | NYJ |
| 27 | Sam Bradford | ARI |
| 28 | Tyrod Taylor | CLE |
| 29 | Mitchell Trubisky | CHI |
| 30 | Joe Flacco | BAL |
| 31 | Josh Allen | BUF |
| 32 | Jamies Winston | TB |